The Celts

February 1, 2025

Cultural historian Stewart's (Univ. of Edinburgh) weighty history explores the evolution of people wanting to claim Celtic identity for their nations. With examinations of research, theories, and sometimes outright forgeries of antiquarians, academics, and eccentric historical enthusiasts, the book shows how a dearth of textual evidence, save for mentions in the classical writings of Caesar and Tacitus, allowed various parties wishing to claim Celtic forebears for their nations (or to denigrate the heritage of their rivals) to shape popular ideas of this ancient people for purposes ranging from religious sectarianism to political ambitions. In Ireland and Brittany, claims to Celtic heritage were used to strengthen independence movements. Patriots in Wales and Scotland sought proof of literary and poetic traditions stretching back to an idealized Celtic past. Stewart elucidates a clearer understanding of the Celts through disciplines such as linguistics and archaeology. His book also explains how theories of race and nationalism worked to confuse and distort matters. VERDICT Stewart's exhaustively researched work will appeal chiefly to scholars of historiography.--Sara Shreve

Copyright 2025 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

February 1, 2025
An iconic people receive a scholar's attention. Stewart, a scholar at the University of Edinburgh, reminds readers that ancient writers (Caesar, Tacitus) recorded Celts as fearless warriors who rampaged across Europe and even sacked Rome. Vanishing from the record for a thousand years, they were rediscovered by Renaissance humanists. Although nowadays associated with Ireland, Wales, and Scotland, the original Celts cast a broader shadow. Never happy with their German ancestry, French academics worked to promote a Gaulish alternative, and British opposition to Anglo-Saxons flourished. The Renaissance was the period when modern European nations took shape, and these humanists, patriots and Christians all, disliked the Roman conviction that all people north of Italy were barbarians. Poring over fragmentary ancient manuscripts but speculating generously, many concluded that their nations' founders were civilized migrants from ancient Egypt, Phoenicia, or Troy; their religious leaders (druids) were precursors of Christianity, and their language a direct descendant of Europe's mother tongue--Hebrew. Much of this was nonsense, or deliberately faked, but Stewart is a dedicated scholar, not a popular historian, so he leaves no stone unturned, and readers will encounter a steady stream of unfamiliar savants, obscure texts, and raging controversies often wacky to modern ears but now forgotten. Persistent readers may perk up as he reaches the 19th century, when history became scientific, although that included the abortive sciences of racism and phrenology, which mostly reinforced English dislike of the Irish. French, English, and German Celtic claims receded, and Stewart's focus narrows to familiar Ireland, Scotland, and Wales, plus a touch of Brittany. Over the last century, Ireland's independence and the elimination of scholarly nonsense have made Celtic studies a respectable academic field. Popular Celticism persists, mostly in Wales and Scotland, as a minority movement more successful in culture than politics. Definitive and encyclopedic.

COPYRIGHT(2025) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.